Improving City Government Policy Management
City leaders know that policies are the invisible framework holding local government together. From HR rules to public safety procedures, policies guide staff in delivering services and complying with laws. But what happens when those policies are stuck in the past? In many cities, policy management hasn’t changed in decades – think dusty binders and PDFs on shared drives. This creates real headaches today: confusion among employees, slower compliance with new regulations, and even risks to public trust.
Consider this: A recent audit in Salt Lake County found 12% of its countywide policies were outdated, some referencing departments that no longer exist. Outdated policies like these aren’t just paperwork – they can lead to serious issues. The county auditor warned that employees may follow incorrect guidelines, “leading to confusion and a potential breakdown of controls”. In other words, when your policies don’t keep up, your organization can’t perform at its best.
The High Cost of Policy Paralysis
Stale policies often equal stalled progress. They make it harder to adapt and can erode confidence both inside and outside City Hall. For example, compliance officers report that keeping policies current with changing laws is a top challenge – in one survey, 42% said training staff on policies and 38% said aligning policies to new regulations were their biggest hurdles. It doesn’t help that many organizations lack a formal update process; only 27% of Chief Compliance Officers were confident their teams had a system to update policies when laws change. This gap means cities risk falling out of compliance simply due to slow policy updates.
The public sees the effects too. Imagine discovering your city code still has decades-old ordinances that no one enforced but never removed – it doesn’t inspire trust. In fact, 82% of residents say transparency in local decisions is essential, but only 41% are satisfied with their government’s info-sharing. Cluttered, inaccessible policy documents contribute to that dissatisfaction. On the flip side, providing clear, updated policies to the public (like an up-to-date online city code or published police procedures) can boost trust. Residents who frequently use their city’s online services are nearly five times more likely to trust their local government, highlighting how openness and modern tools go hand-in-hand with credibility.
Perhaps the most tragic consequences of outdated policies have been seen in public safety. Both Minneapolis and Cleveland learned this the hard way. In Minneapolis, the U.S. Department of Justice found that “persistent deficiencies in policy, training, and accountability” within the police department contributed to unconstitutional practices and eroded community trust. Cleveland’s police force, likewise, operated under old norms until a DOJ consent decree forced a complete policy overhaul – from use-of-force rules to officer training – over the past decade. These examples show that letting policies lag can fuel serious public safety failures and community outrage. The cost to fix such failures (monetarily and in trust) is far higher than the cost to prevent them by keeping policies current.
Modernizing Policies: A Smart Investment, Not a Luxury
The good news is that city leaders are not powerless to change this. Modernizing policy management is very achievable and brings quick wins. At its core, modernization means moving from ad-hoc, paper-based policy handling to a centralized, digital, and proactive approach. Concretely, that could involve adopting a policy management software platform, or simply instituting better processes – like regular policy reviews and a centralized repository that everyone can access.
Several forward-thinking cities have already paved the way. Sacramento, CA, for instance, realized its internal policies were a mess – scattered and sometimes bypassed by staff. They implemented an Automated Policy and Procedure System (APPS) to serve as a one-stop hub for all city policies. Now, instead of hunting through emails or old binders, employees in Sacramento can find the latest HR rule or finance procedure in seconds. The city clerk’s office ensures new or updated policies are published to the central system for all to see. This not only saves staff time but also ensures everyone “drinks from the same well” of accurate information.
Modern policy management also means building compliance into the workflow. Rather than hoping employees read policy changes, the system can require them to acknowledge updates. For example, when Minneapolis rewrites its police use-of-force policy under federal oversight, every officer will likely have to sign off that they’ve read and understood the new rules. Some agencies even include short quizzes or trainings with new policies to reinforce critical points. This creates a culture of accountability: policies aren’t just documents on a shelf, they are actively communicated and integrated into daily operations.
Another key aspect is speed and agility. A modernized city can update a policy quickly when needed. Think about the early days of COVID-19 – governments had to issue new workplace safety policies almost overnight. Cities with agile policy systems could disseminate those changes citywide via email links or an intranet, ensuring all departments responded uniformly. In contrast, cities reliant on paper manuals were scrambling to inform everyone and often ended up with inconsistent practices. With the pace of change only accelerating (consider new cybersecurity mandates, police reform laws, etc.), having a nimble policy process is like having a good shock absorber on your car – it helps you handle the bumps without veering off the road.
Lastly, transparency and public access are integral to modernization. Many cities are choosing to publish certain policy manuals for the public. For example, numerous police departments now post their policy manuals online (thanks in part to legislative pushes for transparency). Some cities also provide public-facing portals for city codes or administrative policies, so residents can see how decisions are made. When residents can easily find information – say, the city’s code enforcement policy or the steps for a public hearing – it demystifies government. It also signals that the city has nothing to hide and keeps itself up to date. Given the earlier stat about transparency satisfaction being low, this is a direct way to build goodwill.
Quick Wins and Next Steps
For city managers and department heads wondering where to begin, here are a few actionable steps to kickstart policy modernization:
- Centralize Your Policies: Create a single source (even if it’s a simple SharePoint site or Google Drive) where all city or department policies are stored. This immediately cuts down the “I can’t find the policy” problem. Make sure it’s organized (by department or topic) and accessible to those who need it. In parallel, identify any policies that are obviously outdated and mark them for review.
- Schedule Regular Reviews: Don’t wait 5 years to dust off a policy. Set a cycle (perhaps annually or biennially) where each policy owner must review and either update or confirm the policy is still good. Mark these dates on a calendar or use reminders. This practice alone would have prevented Salt Lake County’s 12-year-old policy language from lingering uncorrected. Assign responsibility – for example, HR reviews HR policies, police department reviews its SOPs, etc., with oversight from a central coordinator.
- Leverage Technology: Evaluate if a policy management software tool is right for your city. Many governments use such platforms to automate version control, approvals, and employee attestations. These tools can be game-changers for efficiency and audit readiness. If budget is an issue, start small – even a well-maintained spreadsheet tracking policies and dates is better than nothing, and you can build the business case for a tool by showing the risks of the current approach (chances are your finance committee will appreciate the risk reduction argument).
- Engage Staff and Public: Modernization isn’t just a top-down IT project; it’s about people. Explain to your employees why you’re updating the policy process – perhaps share anecdotes or data, like how much time gets wasted searching for policies or the potential legal exposures. Likewise, consider informing the public when you make a big update (e.g., “City updates code to remove outdated regulations” – this could make for a positive press release highlighting cutting of red tape or improving transparency). Engaging stakeholders creates support and might surface more ideas to improve.
- Start with High-Impact Areas: If the task seems huge, prioritize areas that pose the most risk or are most overdue. Common high-impact zones are anything legally required (personnel policies, safety regulations) and anything affecting public safety. For example, if your police department hasn’t updated its policy manual in years, that’s a priority (both for community trust and liability reasons). Similarly, if HR policies haven’t been refreshed to comply with new state laws (say, on family leave or gender inclusion), bump that up the list. Early successes in these areas will provide momentum (and political cover) to extend modernization elsewhere.
The bottom line for city leaders is that modernizing policy management is an investment in resilience and effectiveness. It’s a project that may not grab headlines like a new park or tech hub, but it fundamentally strengthens the institution. As one industry stat noted, 63% of organizations found that a strong policy management program helped reduce legal costs and issue resolution time. Who doesn’t want to save money and avoid problems? By cutting down the friction in how policies are handled, you free your team to focus on serving the community, not chasing paperwork or second-guessing procedures.
Modernizing policy management might not be the flashiest initiative, but it’s one that pays dividends across the board. In the words of an old proverb, “Fix the roof while the sun is shining.” Now is the time to fix the metaphorical roof of out-of-date policies before the storm of the next crisis hits. City leaders who champion this cause will see their organizations become more agile, compliant, and trusted – truly a win-win for the public servants and the public they serve.
City policy modernization turns confusion into clarity. By addressing top challenges – like keeping policies updated with regulations (a concern for 38% of orgs) and ensuring staff training (42% cite this) – city leaders can reduce risk. Above: Two leading challenges faced by compliance professionals in 2023.
Download our full e-book, “Policy Management Roadmap for City Leaders” for an in-depth guide, real case studies from Minneapolis, Sacramento, and more statistics on how updated policies can transform your city operations. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to refine your policy process, the roadmap provides step-by-step insights to help you succeed. This is your chance to turn policy management from a pain point into a point of pride for your city. Get the full e-book now and lead the charge in bringing your city’s policies into the modern era!
Robust Tools for Policymakers
Manage the end-to-end policymaking process
What's new
View All
Internal Policy & Compliance in State + Local Government
Every state agency, county, and city runs on internal policies: the rules that tell employees how to hire, spend, secure ...read more
State & Local DOGE Survival Guide: Navigating the Federal Funding Squeeze
At Esper, we partner with state and local governments every day to modernize how policies are drafted, approved, and maintained. ...read more
5 Brutal Challenges Facing Public Health Leaders (and How to Fix Them)
Running a Department of Health isn’t for the faint of heart. You’re balancing fast-moving regulations, emergency response, strategic initiatives, and ...read more